The short answer
Own-occupation disability insurance pays if an injury or illness stops you from practicing dentistry, even if you could earn money doing something else. For most new dentists, the key features are a true own-occupation definition, residual benefits, a future increase option and a non-cancelable policy.
Most new dentists with loans should have an individual own-occupation policy
- Your hands and back are your income, and your loans don't stop if you can't work.
- Buying while young and healthy usually means fewer exclusions and more options.
- Group or association coverage alone often has gaps; check the definition of disability.
Some links on this page pay us when you check a rate or sign up. It costs you nothing and never changes our rankings. How we make money.
Why dentists need it more than most
Your income depends on fine motor control, your eyes, your neck and your back. A tremor, a hand injury or a herniated disc can end clinical dentistry while leaving you able to do other work.
That’s the problem most disability policies don’t solve. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) notes that definitions vary. Some policies pay if you can’t do your own job; others pay only if you can’t do any job you’re qualified for. A dentist who can still teach or consult may get nothing under the second kind.
Meanwhile, your loans keep coming due. A new dentist with $300,000 at 8.07% accrues about $2,000 a month in interest alone.
The definitions that matter
Own occupation. The policy pays if you can’t perform the duties of your own occupation. Read how “occupation” is defined: as a dentist, or as your dental specialty.
True own occupation. You collect full benefits even if you go on to work and earn in another field or another area of dentistry. Some policies instead reduce or stop benefits once you earn money elsewhere. That weaker version is sometimes called “modified” or “transitional” own occupation, so ask which one you’re getting.
Specialty-specific. If you’re an oral surgeon, endodontist or orthodontist, look for language that defines your occupation as your specialty. Otherwise a surgeon who can still do general exams may not count as disabled.
Any occupation. You’re paid only if you can’t do any job you’re reasonably suited for. This is common in cheaper and group plans, and it’s the one to avoid as your only coverage.
The riders that matter
Residual (partial) benefits. NAIC describes this as coverage that fills the income gap when a partial disability reduces your earnings. For a dentist who can work three days instead of five, this is often the benefit that actually pays. It can be built in or added as a rider.
Future increase option. Your benefit is set by your income when you buy. NAIC notes that you may be able to buy more coverage later as your income rises. A future increase option lets you add coverage later without new medical underwriting, which matters if your health changes.
Cost-of-living adjustment (COLA). NAIC points out that not all policies adjust for inflation. A COLA rider raises your benefit during a long claim, for an added premium. For someone disabled at 30, a claim can last decades.
Non-cancelable and guaranteed renewable. A non-cancelable policy continues at the same price and coverage as long as you pay on time. Guaranteed renewable means the insurer must renew, but can raise premiums for a whole class of policyholders. Non-cancelable and guaranteed renewable together locks both.
Waiting period and benefit length. NAIC notes that longer waiting periods mean lower premiums, and shorter benefit periods mean lower premiums but benefits that can run out. NAIC notes benefit terms can run from one year to retirement age. Pick a waiting period you could cover from savings.
Why buy during school or residency
Insurers generally price and underwrite a policy on your age and health when you apply. A new diagnosis later can mean exclusions or higher premiums, so buying while healthy usually gives you more options.
The ADA gives student members disability coverage, paid for by ADA Members Insurance Plans, during dental school and residency. Check the definition of disability and the benefit cap: student plans are a floor, not a replacement for an individual policy. The ADA also offers a graduate conversion to its member plan.
NAIC notes that coverage through a professional organization can cost less than an individual policy. The trade-off is that association and employer group plans can be changed or cancelled for the whole group. Check the renewability terms before relying on one.
How much coverage to buy
NAIC says a typical disability benefit is about 60% of pre-disability earned income. Carriers cap how much they’ll issue based on your income, and they count other coverage you already have.
Start with what you’d need to live on. NAIC suggests adding up housing, food, transportation, utilities and health costs, then adding your loan payments.
Example: an associate earning $180,000 might need $8,000 a month to cover living costs and loan payments. Carriers often cap benefits around 60% of income, which here is roughly $9,000 a month; actual limits vary by carrier and income. That associate would likely want close to the maximum, plus a future increase option for later raises.
Taxes change the math. NAIC notes that benefits from an individual policy you pay for yourself are generally income tax-free. If an employer pays for a group plan, some of the benefit may be taxable.
Who needs it, and who can wait
It’s usually right for you now if you’re a D4, resident or associate with loans and no large savings. The earlier you apply, the more options you usually have.
You might wait or buy less if you have no debt and substantial assets, or a spouse’s income covers your household. Even then, compare the cost to what a long disability would do to your plans.
Don’t let an employer’s group plan be your only coverage without reading it. NAIC notes group coverage usually isn’t transferable to another job. Its definition of disability may also be weaker than an individual policy’s, so read it.
What to do next
- If you’re an ADA student member, activate the student coverage now. The ADA plan pays its premium, so it’s a floor while you shop.
- Write down your monthly needs, including loan payments. The RAP guide can help estimate federal payments.
- Get quotes from several carriers through an independent broker such as Pattern. Ask for true own-occupation, specialty-specific language if you’re a specialist, residual benefits, a future increase option and non-cancelable terms.
- Compare the policy language, not just the premium. Ask the broker to show the definition of disability word for word.
- Before you apply, confirm the agent and company are licensed with your state insurance department.
- Next, check whether you need term life insurance.
Written by Ryan Smith, DDS (draft awaiting his approval). Review by a certified student loan professional is pending. This page is general education, not financial, tax or legal advice for your situation. Found a mistake? Tell us.